Catrice Lash Obsessed Lash Glue & Eyeliner Review

By Maychiri's Thoughts - March 09, 2025

The first review for today is something I had been thinking about buying for the longest time, and it’s the Catrice Lash Obsessed Lash Glue & Eyeliner.
 
 
Now, I used to not use eyeliners often because I was not too skilled with them and it always took me way too long to perfect my flicks. But, as this is a glue and eyeliner in one, and I had started using falsies when I bought this eyeliner, I thought it would be useful to have something that, as the saying goes, kills two birds with one stone (please don’t throw stones at birds though!!!). I immediately went and bought another one to have a spare just in case because it was 50% off in DM. But was it wise to buy a replacement before even trying it out? Well, let's see!
 
 

First, the packaging: it came in a gold/black cardboard packaging that looked rather modern. The eyeliner itself is reflective gold and looks super modern and more expensive than it really is. I really love the way it looks! The cap closes very tightly.
 

 

Ingredients: hyaluronic acid for nourishment and no parabens. It’s very good that Catrice included HA so that it isn’t at all drying. The scent is subtle, somewhat plasticy or like glue (makes sense, this is glue after all). The expiration date is 6 months after opening.
 
 
 
This is a felt tip pen type of eyeliner, which is super easy to use, especially for beginners, and is terrifically precise. The tip is pointed, which makes it so easy to draw wings or geometric eyeliners, and there isn’t usually a lot of tugging while applying it. It deposits pigment extremely easily and evenly, except when it has already dried, then it can be a bit difficult to fix mistakes.  
 
 
 
 
 
 
There is no smudging while applying it and I didn’t notice any bleeding or smudging later, either. The formula is quite liquidy at first, but it quickly dries and becomes very tacky, allowing you to stick eyelashes to it. The strength of the glue is satisfying, and I find it holds my falsies very well. I really like both the felt tip and the formula as it’s super easy to use!
 
 
 
 
The pigmentation is jet black, so, very intense, even with just one layer. The texture is not really totally matte; there is a bit of sheen, especially while it is still wet. I would’ve preferred it to be ultra matte, but this is alright too. It dries within seconds, turning from a regular ol’ eyeliner to an eyelash glue. It feels tacky when I touch it and it can also feel a bit tacky and tight on my eyelids. It’s not uncomfortable though. 
 
 
 
Worn with Trend It Up Big Lash Love False Lashes [Natural]

And I must mention that it doesn’t irritate eyes at all even if you do get some of it in them, as has happened to me while tightlining. 
 
 
Worn with Essence Lash Princess Wispy Effect False Lashes
 
As for the longevity, I can safely say that it is extremely long-lasting. I usually wear it for more than 6 hours and there is absolutely no change in how it looks or feels, unless I keep touching it for whatever reason. It stays just as black and there is no bleeding or smudging. It also didn’t end up cracking after drying. The glue also holds extremely well for hours, and if I glue the lashes properly in the first place they don’t budge, even 6 hours later. The only place where they might end up popping off is in the inner eye, which isn’t surprising, but even that happens relatively rarely. 
 

Wearing just this eyeliner, with no falsies

This eyeliner is terribly difficult to remove, sadly. The only thing that removed it with ease was the Nivea oil-based remover which has been discontinued, so now I have to struggle to remove it. To be fair, makeup remover I used isn’t too good and struggles to remove more durable makeup like eyeliners or liquid lipsticks, so it’s no surprise that it cannot remove this eyeliner. I have to clean my eyes multiple times to completely remove the Eeeliner, and then finish it with micellar water. This all ends up irritating my sensitive eyes, but I guess that extreme durability has to have a price.
 

Just one more thing to note: if I have to fix this eyeliner after it has already become tacky it ends up clogging the felt tip. That made me throw the first one in the bin after only a couple of uses because I just couldn’t get it to deposit pigment anymore. That’s a pretty big flaw I must say, because not everyone is a master at drawing flicks so most will probably need to keep fixing their wings. Don’t get me wrong, you can be finicky and keep fixing it, just be very quick about it. And I couldn’t have cleaned the tip with micellar water or something because it is extremely difficult to remove anyways.
 

 
Conclusion: this eyeliner was a real pleasant surprise I must say! It’s both a very good eyeliner and really good eyelash glue. The pigment is jet black, and the felt tip pen is super easy to use and really precise. It makes drawing winged eyeliners really easy, even if you are an amateur, thanks to the extremely precise tip and liquidy formula. The finish is something between matte and glossy. It’s extremely durable, and just as difficult to remove, requiring a lot of rubbing and repeat cleansing to completely remove it. But this is also eyelash glue, and it’s a bloody good one, too! As soon as it becomes tacky after applying it you can put eyelashes on it and it will hold them in place throughout the day. It’s not the strongest glue, naturally, but it is plenty strong nevertheless. So, it really works as both an eyeliner and an eyelash glue, the advertisement was not false! I grew to really like it, which makes it all the more sad that it’s part of a limited edition; it really ought to be part of the regular selection of products. So, sadly, once I am done with the second pen I won’t be able to buy it anymore! These limited editions that Catrice and Essence put out every other month can be a bit annoying if you find something you actually really like. In any case, if anyone finds this eyeliner and likes to use false eyelashes, don’t hesitate to buy it, it’s brilliant! Recommendation!
 
 
 
Rating: 7/10
 
 
Would buy again? YES (if it weren’t part of an LE)



  • Share:

0 comments